When designs go bad: iPod Shuffle 3G

I recently bought an iPod Shuffle 3G (3rd Generation) from the Apple Store to use while in the gym (I did try my iPhone 3GS first but after accidentally throwing it 6 feet in the air, I felt that it was better left in the gym locker).

I had wanted a shuffle for a while but the cost per GB seemed a bit steep. So when the 3G was released with a price reduction to £45 for the 4GB version, I jumped at the chance. Finally I wouldn’t have to listen to endless loops of Cascada and Dizzy Rascal on the jukebox! The main feature of the 3G Shuffle is the lack of volume/play controls on the device. All controls are now on a little switch on the earbud cable. They have a proprietary chip that make the player incompatible with regular earbuds. I know Apple earbuds aren’t the best but my iPhone ones work fine for me so it wasn’t a big issue.

On opening, it is a thing of beauty, simple and elegant, as you come to expect from Apple. I painstakingly created my “Gym Workout” playlist and copied it onto the shuffle. Off I went to the gym and everything was great. For the first hour that is. Then I noticed that the annoying computer voice kept interrupting my and telling my what playlist I was listening to. Again and again. It even interrupted itself! Then, the sound controls stopped working and eventually the main play/pause button stopped working. So off I went to see my local Apple Expert and he was happy to give me a new set of earbuds. The next day I took my new earbuds to the gym and within 20 minutes, they too had failed.

It seems pretty clear that the chip inside the earbuds doesn’t like moisture and is not well protected, which is not a good thing when the primary use of the player is for listening to music while exercising. A quick look around the Internet and its clear that I am not the only one with this problem. To make things worse, because of the proprietary earbud chips, there aren’t a lot of options. There are some accessories on the Apple Store that allow you to use regular earbuds such as the Scosche tapLINE extension lead and tapStick but they are relatively expensive and when added to a new set of earphones are more expensive that the Shuffle itself! I haven’t tested these yet so I don’t know if they are resistant to moisture.

It says a lot about a product when you have to spend more than the original cost to make it suitable for its task. I am afraid I have to give the iPod Shuffle 3G a big fat “F minus” and recommend anyone looking for an mp3 player for exercise to avoid it like the plague. Sort it out Apple!!